We publish our audit record because accuracy claims should be checkable. Every entry on this site runs through an automated fact-audit pipeline (accuracy audit → source-grounded repair → visual QA); this page is generated from that pipeline's own report, not written by hand.
This is a fiction/fan codex: entries describe an in-universe canon. Our audits check canon and internal consistency — external fact-checking does not apply the way it does on real-subject codexes.
Last full accuracy audit: 2026-08-23 · 30 entries checked · 9 flagged · 22 issues confirmed · 9 corrected · 13 still open
Manute — Manute was not crucified by the Old Town girls under Miho's direction; in the canon, he was crucified by the Old Town girls under Gail's direction, not Miho's.
Manute — Manute did not lose an eye inflicted by Marv; in the canon, he lost an eye to Dwight McCarthy's gunfire during the events of 'A Dame to Kill For'.
Marv's Associates — Marv does not appear in *Blue Eyes*
Marv's Associates — Marv's public defender is killed by corrupt police, not by Kevin and Cardinal Roark's men
The Roach — The entry states that Dwight McCarthy confronts the Yellow Bastard at the Roark family's farm; in canon, Dwight does not confront the Yellow Bastard there—Hartigan kills the Yellow Bastard at the farm.
The Roach — The entry claims Dwight McCarthy is driven by vengeance and has turned into 'something less than human' in his quest for justice, but in 'That Yellow Bastard', Dwight is not the protagonist and does not confront the Yellow Bastard; this description conflates h
Dwight McCarthy — Dwight appears in more yarns than any other figure: Marv appears in more yarns.
Dwight McCarthy — Dwight appears briefly in Hell and Back: Dwight does not appear in Hell and Back.
Becky's Porcelain Doll — The LORE says 'Handler purchased three Lilli dolls, giving one to Barbara and bringing two back to Mattel' — this is incorrect; she brought one back to Mattel, not two.
Hartigan's Badge — John Hartigan does not appear in Kadie's bar during *The Hard Goodbye*; the scene of Hartigan in Kadie's bar occurs in *That Yellow Bastard*.
That Yellow Bastard — The girl's name is Nancy, not Becky.
That Yellow Bastard — Roark Junior is not known as 'the Yellow Bastard' before his disfigurement.
That Yellow Bastard Part Two — The entry states 'That Yellow Bastard Part Two' is a separate story arc, but in the original Sin City comics, 'That Yellow Bastard' is a single, self-contained story (not divided into parts) that appears in the first collected volume. There is no canonical 'Pa
That Yellow Bastard Part Two — The entry claims the story follows Detective John Hartigan protecting 'eleven-year-old Nancy Callahan,' but in the canon, Nancy Callahan is introduced as a young girl, but her exact age is not consistently stated as eleven; more importantly, the story spans ye
All content is fetchable as JSON at /data/content/ · llms.txt · sitemap
Spotted an error? Suggest an edit — reader reports go straight into the audit queue.